The Secret Burger Society

I'd say Secret Burger Society is the pick of the bunch in Randwick, consistently solid, and offer online ordering and payment through Eatclub, something I'd like to see more of from other venues. Smashed patty, loads of bacon, crisp salad, and while the sauce is a sweet mayo, I'd prefer less sweet with maybe aioli.

This was a good item to get a feel for how the restaurant does a burger - hence it lived up to the name. The milk bun was soft, the beef juicy and not cooked rock hard while the sauce and cheese were a nice compliment. Having picked up takeaway, the only slight downside was that the burger was only warm when I got to eat it and not hot. It’s a shame the restaurant had no nearby parking.

Besides the overcooked bacon, this burger was delicious. Juicy chicken and a tasty buffalo taste throughout. The red chili bun wasn't as dense as I expected it to be.

Decent burger I guess.. Was frustrating because for some reason mimo burger became available on DD on to find out it was a mistake. That meant I was hangry when this came... First time ordering a double on delivery and it was much warmer than normal +1 The chips though. In a plastic bag 🤦🏼‍♂️ you’ll be depositing them straight in the bin once they arrive so don’t bother ordering them

This review is for the Brotherhood of Chicken🐔. It’s not populating on the menu, even though I tried to add it last week. Comes with a milk bun, fried chicken fillet, American cheese and Mayo (secret sauce?). Not gonna lie - had relatively high hopes for this place but overall it was quite disappointing. Should have known this when I mentioned TBC and showed the cashier the deal for the free fries and the guy just shrugged and said he doesn’t know what that is and won’t honor it. Decided to get two burgers - the Secret Burger and the Brotherhood of Chicken. I had the latter once before through delivery and was pretty solid and wanted to give it another go. This one was also quite disappointing. The chicken was overcooked and the quality of thigh was pretty poor. Had some cartilage and was quite dark and chewy. Too much mayo for my liking and I should have hacked it with some hot sauce. The cheese wasn’t very melted either, as you can see in the pic.

This review is for the Secret Burger 🍔. Comes with a milk bun, grass fed beef, American cheese, crispy bacon, pickles, lettuce, tomato, and secret sauce. Not gonna lie - had relatively high hopes for this place but overall it was quite disappointing. Should have known this when I mentioned TBC and showed the cashier the deal for the free fries and the guy just shrugged and said he doesn’t know what that is and won’t honor it. Decided to get two burgers - the Secret Burger and the Brotherhood of Chicken. I had the latter once before through delivery and was pretty solid and wanted to give it another go. The Secret Burger needs to remain a secret - as no one should go there and order it 😏 beef was super dry, bun was dry, and there wasn’t much sauce. Way too much lettuce too as you can see in the pic. Didn’t even want to finish this one. Woof.

🤫🍔The Secret Burger 🤫🍔 🥩 Grass Fed Beef 🧀 Deep Fried Cheese Patty (added) 🧀 American Cheese 🥓 Crispy Maple Bacon 🥒 Pickles 🥗 Lettuce, Tomato 💦 Secret Sauce First time I had this burger was in Mascot a couple of years ago and it was one of the softest melt in your mouth burgers. Technically back then it was called the Phat Cheesus but I recreated it minus the chipotle mayo. It's still good now but it's definitely not as good as it was before hitting that 4.8 and 4.8+ burgers are always very memorable haha. Also if you scroll down to the first review on the app for this place you will see exactly what I mean. Make note the Hi- Melt cheesy patty so it's fucking hot lol